Today, the Federal Housing Administration announced in FHA Info #18-47 that effective tomorrow, Friday, November 30, 2018, the protocols that had been in place on an interim basis for the HECM second appraisal requirement will become fully automated.
FHA published FHA Info #18-47 as a reminder for appraisal logging guidance, along with the effective date for the automation of the HECM second appraisal protocols. For additional information, refer to the Fully-Automated Protocols outlined on page five of Mortgagee Letter 18-06.
- All appraisals logged in FHA Connection (FHAC) through today, Thursday, November 29, 2018, will continue to be processed using the Interim Protocols as described in Mortgagee Letter 18-06. The Interim Protocols must be followed on these cases throughout the entire process.
- Initial appraisals logged in FHAC for the first time, beginning tomorrow, Friday, November 30 and thereafter, will be processed under the Fully-Automated Protocols as described in Mortgagee Letter 18-06. The new protocol is effective even if the initial appraisal was uploaded into the Electronic Appraisal Delivery (EAD) system prior to Friday, November 30, but not logged in FHAC until November 30, or thereafter.
- For appraisals processed under the Fully-Automated Protocols (initial appraisal logged in FHAC November 30, 2018, and thereafter), once the appraisal logging is completed, a lender will immediately receive one of the following messages on the FHAC Logging Screen
- A: SECOND APPRAISAL IS NOT REQUIRED
- B: PROPERTY SUBJECT TO HECM APPRAISAL RULE SECOND APPRAISAL REQUIRED (see Fully-Automated Protocols in Mortgagee Letter 18-06)
Depending on the message received, the lender should proceed accordingly. No further action is required if message A is received. However, if message B is received, the lender must obtain and upload a second appraisal into the Appraisal Slot 2 position.
- When a second appraisal is needed under the Fully-Automated Protocols, it must always be uploaded into the EAD in Appraisal Slot 2, regardless if the new value is equal to, more than, or less than the initial appraisal. FHAC will automatically calculate the lowest value to be used for insuring.
- Under no circumstances should a second appraisal be uploaded into the EAD in Appraisal Slot 1; it must be uploaded into Appraisal Slot 2.
For questions or additional information about FHA’s new automated appraisal logging procedures for HECMs, contact the FHA Resource Center.